Question
22 mag
- Cinese tradizionale (Taiwan)
-
Giapponese
-
Inglese (Stati Uniti)
-
Inglese (Regno Unito)
Risposte
22 mag
Domanda in primo piano
- Inglese (Stati Uniti)
The whole story is told in the past tense.
(Most stories are told in past tense)
"Had" is past tense. "Has" is present tense.
If the sentence was a quote of something that Big Nutbrown Hare said or exactly what he thought, then it would be
"But I have even longer arms," said Big Nutbrown Hare.
or
But I have even longer arms, thought Big Nutbrown Hare.
Since it is just the storyteller saying that Big Nutbrown Hare's arms were longer, it is in past tense.
---------------------------------------
It is possible, but much less common, to tell a whole story in the present tense, but it is only done when the storyteller is IN the story, and still it is done for specific effect, to imply something about the storyteller's character.
I don't expect you will ever see it in a children's book.
In spoken speech, some people tell stories this way.
It is actually difficult to completely stick to present tense when telling a story, because the story did happen in the past.
Utente esperto
Leggi ulteriori commenti

Utente eliminato
Books are usually either past tense, or present tense.
In this case, past. So they use "had"
- Cinese tradizionale (Taiwan)
@Kiwi_1
Yes. But why “Hmm, that is a lot” ?
Yes. But why “Hmm, that is a lot” ?

Utente eliminato
@loveuwithomyheart Because the character is thinking that. The narrator speaks in past tense, but the characters speak in present.
- Cinese tradizionale (Taiwan)

Utente eliminato
@loveuwithomyheart Because the character is thinking. He's saying it in his head, but not to his friend.
- Cinese tradizionale (Taiwan)
@Kiwi_1
Oh!!! So even don’t need to have “ “
It can also be present tense!!!
Oh!!! So even don’t need to have “ “
It can also be present tense!!!
- Inglese (Stati Uniti)
The whole story is told in the past tense.
(Most stories are told in past tense)
"Had" is past tense. "Has" is present tense.
If the sentence was a quote of something that Big Nutbrown Hare said or exactly what he thought, then it would be
"But I have even longer arms," said Big Nutbrown Hare.
or
But I have even longer arms, thought Big Nutbrown Hare.
Since it is just the storyteller saying that Big Nutbrown Hare's arms were longer, it is in past tense.
---------------------------------------
It is possible, but much less common, to tell a whole story in the present tense, but it is only done when the storyteller is IN the story, and still it is done for specific effect, to imply something about the storyteller's character.
I don't expect you will ever see it in a children's book.
In spoken speech, some people tell stories this way.
It is actually difficult to completely stick to present tense when telling a story, because the story did happen in the past.
Utente esperto
- Cinese tradizionale (Taiwan)
- Inglese (Stati Uniti)
Yes, so just to clarify
the whole sentence is
Hmm, that is a lot, thought Little Nutbrown Hare.
THOUGHT is past tense because it is in the time perspective of the storyteller telling a story that happened in the past.
IS is present tense because it is a thought in the head of the character, which from the character's time perspective is in the present. Like a spoken quote (using "...") it is an exact report so the tense cannot change from what it was when it happened.
It was present tense for the character when it was thought.
It is past tense for the storyteller at the time of telling.
@Kiwi_1 has also given you an excellent and very thorough explanation.
Utente esperto
- Cinese tradizionale (Taiwan)

[Novità] Ehi tu! Dico a te che stai imparando una lingua!
Sai come migliorare le tue abilità linguistiche❓ Basta far correggere ciò che scrivi da un madrelingua!
Con HiNative, puoi ricevere correzioni su ciò che scrivi da utenti madrelingua gratis ✍️✨.
Con HiNative, puoi ricevere correzioni su ciò che scrivi da utenti madrelingua gratis ✍️✨.
Registrazione
domande simili
- Qual è la differenza tra it has been raining e it has rained ?
- I have to stay whether you will go or not これは自然ですか?
- "I already have it" is natural?
Domande Recenti
- does anyone know any free books/pdfs online that i could use to help learn the italian language?
- Could you recommend one country among Southern France, Spain and Italy for a trip in Winter? I l...
- Parafrasate, per favore da predestinato. Un impatto importante sul campionato, a soli 21 anni. ...
- Questa frase è naturale? Chiedendo aiuto di HiNative, provo a leggere un libro intero.
- Ciao qualcuno potrebbe dirmi quanto è 22 milioni?
Topic Questions
- Could you recommend one country among Southern France, Spain and Italy for a trip in Winter? I l...
- Questa frase è naturale? Chiedendo aiuto di HiNative, provo a leggere un libro intero.
- In questa frase è corretto usare il presente? "Il tempo, mi avevano raccontato i miei amici, r...
- In questa frase è corretto usare il passato prossimo? "Avevo letto su un libro che il cammino ...
- È scritto giusto? - è un cantico religioso, cristiano, e i pronomi possesivi posso prendere un a...
Domande suggerite
- what is correct? Where are you study? Or Where do you study? Thank you.
- what should I answer with "How's your day?" "How's It going?" example plz can I say "pretty good"?
- How to respond to "I hope you are doing well"?
- If you are not the correct person, please direct me the correct one. Does this sentence sound nat...
- When I reply to a mail from my boss, can I use "Noted with thanks "? Isn't it rude to my boss?
Previous question/ Next question